Home › Finance & Money › Health Insurance Calculator
Health Insurance Calculator
Open enrollment forces a bet: pay more every month for a plan that protects you, or pay less and gamble on a healthy year. This free health insurance calculator settles the bet with arithmetic — put two plans side by side, add the care you actually expect to use, and see the true yearly cost of each, premiums included.
The currency only changes the symbol and formatting — it never converts amounts.
The total cost of the care you expect to use — prescriptions, visits, treatment — before insurance pays anything.
| Plan A | Plan B | |
|---|---|---|
| Premiums (12 months) | — | — |
| You pay toward the deductible | — | — |
| You pay in coinsurance | — | — |
| Your care payments (after out-of-pocket cap) | — | — |
| Estimated total yearly cost | — | — |
| Worst case (care payments hit the out-of-pocket max) | — | — |
How it works
A health plan charges you in two separate ways: the premium, which you pay every month whether you see a doctor or not, and cost-sharing, which you pay when you actually use care. Comparing premiums alone is how people end up "saving" $100 a month and then paying $3,000 extra in a bad spring. This calculator adds both parts together for a realistic year.
The model is deliberately simple, and it is worth knowing exactly what it assumes. You pay the full price of care until your spending reaches the deductible. Above the deductible you pay your coinsurance share of each further dollar — 20% means you pay twenty cents and the plan pays eighty. Your deductible and coinsurance payments together can never exceed the out-of-pocket maximum; past that, covered care costs you nothing more that year. If your expected care costs less than the deductible, you simply pay it all yourself.
What the model leaves out, honestly: real plans drip these costs out service by service, some visits and prescriptions carry flat copays instead of coinsurance, some care is covered before the deductible, and networks, formularies, and HSA tax savings can all move a close call. Run the comparison at a low-spend year and a high-spend year — if the same plan wins both, the choice is easy; if the winner flips, you are really deciding how much risk you want to carry.
Worked example
The two plans above are the defaults, and the expected care is $8,000 — a year with a minor procedure in it. Silver Plan: premiums are $450 × 12 = $5,400. Of the $8,000 care, the first $1,500 is the deductible, and the remaining $6,500 is charged at 20% coinsurance = $1,300, so care payments total $2,800 — under the $6,000 cap. Estimated year: $5,400 + $2,800 = $8,200. Gold Plan: premiums are $620 × 12 = $7,440. Care: $500 deductible plus 10% of the remaining $7,500 = $750, so $1,250 in care payments. Estimated year: $7,440 + $1,250 = $8,690. The cheaper-premium Silver plan wins this year by $490 — but look at the worst-case row: if care payments run to the cap, Gold's lower out-of-pocket max makes its worst year $10,940 against Silver's $11,400. Drop expected care to $800 and Silver wins by even more ($6,200 against $7,970), because neither deductible really bites; Gold only pulls ahead in a heavy year — past roughly $12,900 of care, its gentler cost-sharing overcomes the premium gap. The ranking honestly depends on the year you think you will have.
Before you decide on the estimate alone
Check your doctors and prescriptions first. A plan that wins by $490 but excludes your cardiologist or your medication is not a saving. Networks and formularies outrank arithmetic.
Weigh the worst case, not just the expected case. The out-of-pocket maximum is the number that decides whether a bad year is painful or ruinous. If the two worst cases differ by thousands and the expected costs are close, the safer plan is usually worth it.
Count employer money. If your employer contributes to an HSA with one plan, or pays a bigger share of one premium, use the premium figure you actually pay and remember the HSA contribution is real money in that plan's favor.
FAQ
Why is the cheaper-premium plan not always the cheaper plan overall?
Because the premium is only the entry fee. A low-premium plan usually makes you pay more of each bill yourself through a higher deductible and coinsurance, so in a year with real medical needs it can cost more in total than a higher-premium plan with gentler cost-sharing. The total — twelve premiums plus what you would pay for care — is the only fair comparison, which is what this calculator adds up.
How does the calculator estimate what I pay for care?
It uses a simplified model. You pay the full expected care cost until you reach the deductible, then your coinsurance share of the amount above the deductible, and your total payments for care are capped at the plan's out-of-pocket maximum. Real plans apply deductibles and copays service by service, and some services are covered before the deductible, so treat the result as a planning estimate, not a quote.
What should I enter as my expected yearly medical spend?
Enter the full price of the care you expect to use in a year, before insurance pays anything — regular prescriptions, routine visits, therapy, and a reasonable allowance for the unexpected. If you are healthy and rarely see a doctor, a few hundred may be realistic. If you have ongoing treatment, add it up honestly: the ranking of two plans often flips between a low-spend year and a high-spend year, so try both.
What is the out-of-pocket maximum?
It is the most you can be made to pay for covered, in-network care in a plan year — deductible and coinsurance payments count toward it, premiums do not. Once your care payments reach the out-of-pocket maximum, the plan pays 100% of covered care for the rest of the year. It is the worst-case guardrail, and for anyone expecting surgery or expensive medication it can matter more than the premium.
Does this calculator cover employer contributions or subsidies?
Enter the premium you actually pay each month — after any employer contribution or marketplace subsidy — and the comparison stays correct, because only your own outlay counts. The calculator does not model HSA or FSA tax savings, copay cards, or family-versus-individual deductibles; if those apply to you, they can shift a close result.
Does the currency selector change the amounts?
No. The currency selector only changes the symbol and number formatting shown — dollars, euros, pounds, rupees, and 20 other currencies. It never converts amounts between currencies, so the numbers stay exactly the same whichever currency you pick.